Is juicing good for you? A dietitian explains the benefits and drawbacks
Juicing is the act of extracting only the liquid from fruits and vegetables, then drinking the result.
But is juicing healthy? If so, how often should you do it? And, is juicing safe for cancer patients?
We went to Binsy Thomas, a senior clinical dietitian at UT MD Anderson. Here’s what she wants you to know about juicing.
Are there any real benefits to juicing?
I think it depends on how much you’re juicing, and why. If it’s just once a day or maybe as a snack, that could be OK. But if you’re drinking only juice, all day long, I would say that is not nutritionally beneficial.
On the other hand, it’s hard for some of our patients to eat entire fruits or vegetables rather than just drinking the juice. And, every bite or sip counts when you’re trying to boost your caloric intake. But if you’re looking for a quick way to take in more nourishment, we’d likely recommend a protein drink or a smoothie with protein powder over a juice, because it will offer you more nutritional benefit.
From a health standpoint, though, it’s still much better to eat a variety of foods throughout the day. So, talk to your care team if you’re struggling in this area.
What are the disadvantages of juicing?
Well, you’re not getting enough macronutrients, for one. If you’re only juicing, you’re not getting enough protein to maintain your muscle mass. And you’re not getting the fats your body needs to absorb vitamins like A, D, E and K. So, if you’re not getting those things, then there’s definitely a nutritional deficiency present.
If you’re removing the peel, pulp and seeds from fruits and vegetables, you’re also not getting any of the benefits of fiber, which makes you feel full faster and for longer. Removing that component can also make your blood sugar spike because there’s nothing to slow down its absorption.
Is there any merit to claims that drinking only juices can ‘cleanse’ your body?
No. Ultimately, the body doesn’t function that way. If you have good kidney and liver function, then that is your cleanser. That’s what’s going to help remove anything toxic from your body — not a juice cleanse.
What about smoothies? Are they any healthier than juices?
Yes. You typically add things to smoothies that can be beneficial, like protein powder and yogurt, instead of subtracting things like peel, pulp and seeds.
Is it healthy to juice every day?
If you’re still taking in a variety of other foods, too, then I think it’s fine, in moderation. But if that’s all you’re doing every day, all the time, then no.
What is the 80/20 rule for juicing?
This is a way to be more vegetable-forward with your juicing, to reduce its sugar content. The idea is to get 80% of your juice from vegetables and the remaining 20% from fruit. Veggie-forward juices will naturally have a lower sugar content than juices made primarily from fruits.
Is juicing safe for cancer patients?
That depends. Some of our patients have to be very careful when handling fresh fruits and vegetables because their immune systems are already suppressed or compromised. If they’re not properly washing their produce, there may still be some contaminants that can cause foodborne illness.
It’s also very important to get enough protein during treatment, because otherwise you can lose muscle mass due to weight loss.
However, if you are a healthy individual with no other issues — such as diabetes or kidney disease — and you’re looking to juice, then a single eight-ounce serving of juice per day is probably OK. But I definitely would not recommend juicing in general to our patients, because then you’re depriving yourself of the key components that you need in your diet. Ask a dietitian to assess your overall daily food intake to ensure that you’re consuming adequate amounts of protein, fiber and healthy fats.
Request an appointment at UT MD Anderson online or call 1-877-632-6789.
Four siblings seek Barrett’s esophagus care at UT MD Anderson
Flap surgery, explained: Common types and what to expect
Breast cancer survivor encourages screening and self-advocacy
Tai chi: Health benefits and how to get started
Glioblastoma caregiver and employee: Beyond the diagnosis
|
$entity1.articleCategory
|
|---|
|
$entity2.articleCategory
|
|
$entity3.articleCategory
|
|
$entity4.articleCategory
|
|
$entity5.articleCategory
|
|
$entity6.articleCategory
|
Find stories by topic
Find out everything you need to know to navigate a cancer diagnosis and treatment from UT MD Anderson’s experts.
Read inspiring stories from patients and caregivers – and get their advice to help you or a loved one through cancer.
Get UT MD Anderson experts’ advice to help you stay healthy and reduce your risk of diseases like cancer.
Learn how UT MD Anderson researchers are advancing our understanding and treatment of cancer – and get to know the scientists behind this research.
Read insights on the latest news and trending topics from UT MD Anderson experts, and see what drives us to end cancer.
Find out what inspires our donors to give to UT MD Anderson, and learn how their generous support advances our mission to end cancer.