Skip to Content

My Mother's Not to Be Told

The situation
My Mother's not to be toldThe patient's son approaches his mother's physician before they are to convene to discuss her condition. He tells the physician that in no uncertain terms is his mother to be told that she has cancer. The mother does not speak English, and so the son will be translating the doctor's words to her when they convene.

Communication issues
In many cultures, family members are the first recipients of information about a patient's cancer. We also see this when families fear the impact that the information will have on the patient and beseech the doctor not to reveal the information.

When family members attempt to control the information the patient will receive, it brings up ethical as well as communication concerns: how to safeguard the patient's autonomy and fulfill one's contract to her.

A language barrier and cultural issues are complicating factors in this scenario; the physician can't simply go and talk one-on-one with the patient, and while using a hospital translator (if available) would be an option, it might be one that antagonizes the family.

What to watch for
This interaction is actually a negotiation. Note the physician's exploration of the son's motives and fears, and then acknowledgement of his feelings. By using these techniques, he is able to avoid a standoff with the son, but maintain the patient's autonomy and the contract he has with her. Note what he asks the son to agree to.

View Vignette: My Mother's Not To Be Told (7:00)
Pearls & Pitfalls: Expert Comment (5:15)

 

Previous PreviousDon't Give Up On My Mother Go to Next Page

Free CME Credit Available

Certain material on this site is available for Continuing Medical Education Credit. To obtain credit you must use the “Earn Free CME Credit Online” link on the left.

Risk Management Education (RME) Credit Available

Certain material on this site is available for Risk Management Education Credit for physicians enrolled in the The University of Texas Professional Liability Insurance Plan only. To obtain credit you must use the “Earn Free Risk Management Credit Online” link on the left.

Applying for both CME and RME?

If you are applying for both CME and RME for the same module, you MUST view the video through the CME link and then print both the CME forms (found on the right side of the video page) and the RME forms (found below the video window) and send to the appropriate offices.


© 2014 The University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center